• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

PegasusPizzeria – Best Authentic Italian Pizza & Wings in Myrtle Beach, SC

Nestled in Myrtle Beach, PegasusPizzeria is a standout local gem known for its authentic Italian-style pizzas and wings. Renovated after eight months, it delivers consistently large, flavorful pies loaded with fresh mozzarella, savory meats, and a perfectly hand-rolled, crispy crust. Customers praise its quick service, reasonable prices, and the owner’s hands-on dedication—often seen crafting each pizza personally. The balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings shines in every bite, making PegasusPizzeria a must-visit on Shore Drive. Whether you crave classic meat lovers or tender wings, this spot offers satisfying, true-to-Italian flavors that leave a lasting impression.

PegasusPizzeria at a glance

  • Address 9400 Shore Dr Phase 1, Myrtle Beach, SC 29572, United States
  • Phone +1 843-692-5120
  • Restaurant type Restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

PegasusPizzeria: Reviews & Ratings

Benjamin Smith
5

UPDATE: June 2023. Pegusus Pizza is back open after 8 months of renovations to the condo building. Still the best Pizza and Wings in the Shore Drive Area. Best pizza in the Shore Drive area. We've ordered pizza 3 separate occasions and it's been consistent and great all three times. Very Large pizza with a huge portion of toppings. I've included a picture of a large meat lovers we ordered. If you call during open hours and no one answers immediately, it usually means the owner is working by himself and is making pizzas in the back. Please call back. You won't be disappointed. I Highly recommend.

Paul Harmon
5

Ordered on a Friday night from a condo just a few minutes away. The food was ready in 15 minutes. Pizza was great! Crust was crunchy and light with a great flavor and the right amount of sauce cheese and toppings. Thaks to the crew who made our Pizza tonight! Delicious

Howard M
4

Pizza and tenders. Well cooked. Reasonably priced. Just one nice Italian gentleman. Bet they do big business in season.

Mark Bowen
5

Excellent pizza. Could be best i ever had. We were a little hesitant at first. But boy were glad we ordered there. Will definitely go back.

Cory Mccrea
5

Best pizza that I've ever had. Authentic Italian. Fresh mozzarella, marinara, and meats. Perfect hand-rolled crust. I highly recommend!

Faviana Rampolla
5

These pizzas are so good, the ingredients are fresh and everything tastes spectacular. I would definitely eat here again.

Ron M.
5

Great pizza and subs. Try the Philly steak sub you will love it. The sauce is the best.

Carlos Perez
5

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Excellent Pizza by the Beach! Our usual pizza place wasn’t open, so we decided to give this one a try—and we’re so glad we did! The pizza was super good—fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. The prices were very reasonable, especially for being right by the beach. Great food, great value, and a pleasant surprise all around. We’ll definitely be coming back!

Location

  • PegasusPizzeria
    PegasusPizzeria
    9400 Shore Dr Phase 1, Myrtle Beach, SC 29572, United States Hotline: +1 843-692-5120

Nestled on Shore Drive in Myrtle Beach, PegasusPizzeria is a standout gem for pizza lovers seeking authentic Italian flavors paired with generous portions and thoughtful craftsmanship. After a significant renovation period, this pizzeria has reclaimed its spot as the go-to destination for locals craving perfectly hand-rolled crusts, fresh mozzarella, and rich marinara sauce. Each pie arrives generously topped, balancing a crunchy, light crust with the right harmony of sauce, cheese, and toppings that never overwhelms.

The dedication behind the scenes is tangible—if the phone doesn’t answer immediately, it’s likely the owner himself artfully preparing each pizza by hand. This hands-on approach translates into consistently excellent quality and attentive service. Customers consistently praise the large portions and authentic taste, often highlighting specialties like the meat lovers pizza and well-cooked tenders. The pizzeria’s commitment to freshness and tradition shines through every bite, making it not just a meal but a genuine experience.

What strikes me most about PegasusPizzeria is the perfect marriage between traditional Italian techniques and the local vibe of Myrtle Beach. The crust is expertly crafted—light yet robust enough to hold ample toppings without sogginess. Each flavor component is distinct yet harmonizes seamlessly, reflecting a kitchen that respects its ingredients. Whether you’re ordering for a quick dinner or a group gathering, PegasusPizzeria delivers on speed and flavor. It’s a place I find myself recommending repeatedly, confident that their pizza and wings remain some of the best on Shore Drive.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards